Most exchanges get Sharia-compliant earn products wrong before they start building.
The failure pattern: see the $4+ trillion Islamic finance market, rush to ship a "halal staking" product, grab a certification, slap a green badge on the UI. Six months later: community backlash, fatwa disputes, reputational damage.
The problem is treating Sharia compliance as a marketing claim instead of an operational architecture. Certification is one checkpoint in a continuous governance system.
This matters now because Binance launched Sharia Earn with Amanie Advisors certification in July 2025. Bybit partnered with CryptoHalal. The bar for legitimacy is set. A sloppy launch will be compared against institutional-grade implementations.
What Makes Crypto Yield Sharia-Compliant?
A halal earn product must avoid three prohibitions:
Riba (interest): Returns cannot come from lending at interest. Most DeFi lending protocols are disqualified.
Gharar (excessive uncertainty): The source of returns must be transparent. "Mystery yield" from undisclosed strategies fails.
Haram activities: No deployment into gambling, alcohol, adult content, or interest-based financial services.
Required structure: The product needs an Islamic contract framework. For earn products, this is typically a
Wakala agreement: the exchange acts as agent (wakeel) managing funds on behalf of users, receiving a pre-agreed fee, while users retain ownership and bear economic risk/reward.
This differs fundamentally from conventional yield products that guarantee returns or use interest-bearing instruments.
Why Certification Alone Fails
Certification establishes:
A Sharia advisory firm reviewed the structure at a point in time
The contract framework was deemed compliant
Initial assets and strategies were approved
Certification does NOT establish:
Ongoing compliance as conditions change
Real-time fund deployment monitoring
Governance for edge cases
User disclosure practices
Three failure modes when certification is treated as a checkbox:
Strategy drift: Certified strategies become unavailable. Operations deploys elsewhere without re-certification. Community notices.
Asset contamination: A compliant token becomes associated with haram activities. Funds remain deployed. Scholars raise concerns.
Disclosure breakdown: Users don't understand return sources. Community assumes interest-based lending. Backlash spreads.
The Launch Checklist
Phase 1: Pre-Certification (8-12 weeks out)
Define product scope:
Which assets? (Binance started with BNB, ETH, SOL)
Which yield strategies?
Which jurisdictions?
What contract structure?
Select Sharia advisory firm:
Tier-1 firms include:
Amanie Advisors: Certified Binance Sharia Earn. Scholars on AAOIFI's Sharia Council.
CryptoHalal: Partnered with Bybit. Digital asset specialists.
ZICO Shariah: Malaysian firm with crypto expertise.
Selection criteria: AAOIFI recognition, prior crypto certification experience, capacity for ongoing advisory.
Prepare submission materials:
Product mechanics documentation
Fund flow diagrams
Yield source list with risk characterization
Smart contract audits
Draft user agreements
Fee structure
Phase 2: Certification (4-8 weeks)
Deliverables from certification:
Sharia Compliance Certificate
Fatwa with detailed reasoning
Conditions and restrictions
Permissible asset list
Excluded activities list
Establish ongoing relationship:
Quarterly review meetings minimum
Material change notification process
New asset/strategy approval process
Annual re-certification
Phase 3: Pre-Launch (4-6 weeks)
Build internal governance:
Create a Sharia Compliance Committee with executive sponsor, product owner, compliance officer, operations lead, and legal.
Decision escalation matrix:
Change Type | Internal Only | SSB Required |
APY adjustment (approved range) | ✓ | |
New yield strategy | ✓ | ✓ |
New asset addition | ✓ | ✓ |
Emergency withdrawal | ✓ | Post-hoc |
Prepare disclosures:
Product Disclosure Statement must include:
Certifying firm and SSB members
Certificate date and validity
Contract structure explanation
Return source explanation (plain language)
Fee structure
Zakat guidance
Build monitoring:
Real-time fund deployment tracking
Compliance dashboard with alerts
Exposure monitoring for flagged protocols
Phase 4: Launch
Staged rollout to key markets first: Saudi Arabia, UAE, Indonesia, Pakistan, Egypt, Qatar.
Enables monitoring community reception and addressing concerns before broader launch.
Launch day requirements:
Product page with compliance badge
Certificate download
FAQ page
Social monitoring for feedback
Phase 5: Ongoing Operations
Monitoring cadence:
Daily: Fund deployment verification
Weekly: Compliance dashboard review
Monthly: SSB update, user inquiry trends
Quarterly: Formal SSB review
Annually: Re-certification
Material change protocol:
Document proposed change
Internal committee review
SSB consultation if material
User notification if terms affected
Implementation and monitoring
Incident response when compliance is questioned:
Acknowledge promptly
Investigate with SSB if needed
Communicate findings transparently
Remediate if confirmed
Update procedures
Infrastructure Requirements
Sharia-compliant earn products require:
Fund segregation: Compliant funds operationally separated from conventional products
Yield source attribution: Track exactly where returns originate (no blended yield)
Real-time monitoring: Verify deployments against approved strategies continuously
Compliance gating: Controls preventing deployment to unapproved protocols
Platforms building programmable stablecoin infrastructure, like RebelFi, have built these capabilities natively: segregated fund flows, transparent yield routing, and embedded compliance checks.
Certification is the beginning. Governance is the product.
The exchanges that build genuine, well-governed Sharia-compliant products capture significant market share. Those treating it as marketing face backlash that erodes trust far beyond the Muslim community.



