Most exchanges get Sharia-compliant earn products wrong before they start building.

The failure pattern: see the $4+ trillion Islamic finance market, rush to ship a "halal staking" product, grab a certification, slap a green badge on the UI. Six months later: community backlash, fatwa disputes, reputational damage.

The problem is treating Sharia compliance as a marketing claim instead of an operational architecture. Certification is one checkpoint in a continuous governance system.

This matters now because Binance launched Sharia Earn with Amanie Advisors certification in July 2025. Bybit partnered with CryptoHalal. The bar for legitimacy is set. A sloppy launch will be compared against institutional-grade implementations.


What Makes Crypto Yield Sharia-Compliant?

A halal earn product must avoid three prohibitions:

Riba (interest): Returns cannot come from lending at interest. Most DeFi lending protocols are disqualified.

Gharar (excessive uncertainty): The source of returns must be transparent. "Mystery yield" from undisclosed strategies fails.

Haram activities: No deployment into gambling, alcohol, adult content, or interest-based financial services.

Required structure: The product needs an Islamic contract framework. For earn products, this is typically a

Wakala agreement: the exchange acts as agent (wakeel) managing funds on behalf of users, receiving a pre-agreed fee, while users retain ownership and bear economic risk/reward.

This differs fundamentally from conventional yield products that guarantee returns or use interest-bearing instruments.


Why Certification Alone Fails

Certification establishes:

  • A Sharia advisory firm reviewed the structure at a point in time

  • The contract framework was deemed compliant

  • Initial assets and strategies were approved

Certification does NOT establish:

  • Ongoing compliance as conditions change

  • Real-time fund deployment monitoring

  • Governance for edge cases

  • User disclosure practices

Three failure modes when certification is treated as a checkbox:

  1. Strategy drift: Certified strategies become unavailable. Operations deploys elsewhere without re-certification. Community notices.

  2. Asset contamination: A compliant token becomes associated with haram activities. Funds remain deployed. Scholars raise concerns.

  3. Disclosure breakdown: Users don't understand return sources. Community assumes interest-based lending. Backlash spreads.


The Launch Checklist

Phase 1: Pre-Certification (8-12 weeks out)

Define product scope:

  • Which assets? (Binance started with BNB, ETH, SOL)

  • Which yield strategies?

  • Which jurisdictions?

  • What contract structure?

Select Sharia advisory firm:

Tier-1 firms include:

  • Amanie Advisors: Certified Binance Sharia Earn. Scholars on AAOIFI's Sharia Council.

  • CryptoHalal: Partnered with Bybit. Digital asset specialists.

  • ZICO Shariah: Malaysian firm with crypto expertise.

Selection criteria: AAOIFI recognition, prior crypto certification experience, capacity for ongoing advisory.

Prepare submission materials:

  • Product mechanics documentation

  • Fund flow diagrams

  • Yield source list with risk characterization

  • Smart contract audits

  • Draft user agreements

  • Fee structure


Phase 2: Certification (4-8 weeks)

Deliverables from certification:

  • Sharia Compliance Certificate

  • Fatwa with detailed reasoning

  • Conditions and restrictions

  • Permissible asset list

  • Excluded activities list

Establish ongoing relationship:

  • Quarterly review meetings minimum

  • Material change notification process

  • New asset/strategy approval process

  • Annual re-certification


Phase 3: Pre-Launch (4-6 weeks)

Build internal governance:

Create a Sharia Compliance Committee with executive sponsor, product owner, compliance officer, operations lead, and legal.

Decision escalation matrix:

Change Type

Internal Only

SSB Required

APY adjustment (approved range)

New yield strategy

New asset addition

Emergency withdrawal

Post-hoc

Prepare disclosures:

Product Disclosure Statement must include:

  • Certifying firm and SSB members

  • Certificate date and validity

  • Contract structure explanation

  • Return source explanation (plain language)

  • Fee structure

  • Zakat guidance

Build monitoring:

  • Real-time fund deployment tracking

  • Compliance dashboard with alerts

  • Exposure monitoring for flagged protocols


Phase 4: Launch

Staged rollout to key markets first: Saudi Arabia, UAE, Indonesia, Pakistan, Egypt, Qatar.

Enables monitoring community reception and addressing concerns before broader launch.

Launch day requirements:

  • Product page with compliance badge

  • Certificate download

  • FAQ page

  • Social monitoring for feedback


Phase 5: Ongoing Operations

Monitoring cadence:

  • Daily: Fund deployment verification

  • Weekly: Compliance dashboard review

  • Monthly: SSB update, user inquiry trends

  • Quarterly: Formal SSB review

  • Annually: Re-certification

Material change protocol:

  1. Document proposed change

  2. Internal committee review

  3. SSB consultation if material

  4. User notification if terms affected

  5. Implementation and monitoring

Incident response when compliance is questioned:

  1. Acknowledge promptly

  2. Investigate with SSB if needed

  3. Communicate findings transparently

  4. Remediate if confirmed

  5. Update procedures


Infrastructure Requirements

Sharia-compliant earn products require:

  • Fund segregation: Compliant funds operationally separated from conventional products

  • Yield source attribution: Track exactly where returns originate (no blended yield)

  • Real-time monitoring: Verify deployments against approved strategies continuously

  • Compliance gating: Controls preventing deployment to unapproved protocols

Platforms building programmable stablecoin infrastructure, like RebelFi, have built these capabilities natively: segregated fund flows, transparent yield routing, and embedded compliance checks.


Certification is the beginning. Governance is the product.

The exchanges that build genuine, well-governed Sharia-compliant products capture significant market share. Those treating it as marketing face backlash that erodes trust far beyond the Muslim community.

Stay Updated with RebelFi

Get the latest DeFi insights, platform updates, and exclusive content delivered to your inbox.